Could God make a hypothetical question even he couldn't answer?
That depends on what God you're thinking of.
Poseidon, for instance didn't have time for intellectual mind games.
Swinging his trident, he was far to busy splashing around fathering plenty of sons, all of them strong, brutal men (like Orion) or monsters (like Polyphemus).
The Babylonian God Bel-Marduk might have been able to perform such a task. But alas, we will never really know.
The Mountie doesn't get a salary from takete, but makes his living on tips alone. Did the Mounties answer change your life? Leave a tip!